This post is dedicated to my friend and colleague, Sonya, who has been following and supporting my wine journey since I arrived in upstate NY six years ago. I had the wonderful opportunity to work with her for a brief time at Empire Merchants when I was running the wine program as the GM at Portico Restaurant.
As a champion of local wine, Sonya loves being informed about what’s trending in the local wine scene whether it be the latest and greatest of new wine releases, under the radar wines, winery news, and local events. She is also interested in seasonal sips and my favorite wine to drink each week. As I’m sure with other wine aficionados, wine tasting and drinking is a very spontaneous activity, especially when you take into account what food you are serving or eating.
For this week’s edition of the Pour, I will share the process of my wine selection, which includes the season of the year, occasion/drinking establishment, under the radar or discovery of a new grape/wine, recent wine reviews/ratings, and general feeling and mood. For the latter, the relationship between wine and psychology is a very powerful thing. As a psychology major, former bartender, and current wine steward, I can attest to the psychological implications of what to drink and when to drink it.
Many years ago, I did a piece on drinking personalities based on my experience as a server and consumer of alcohol. Although a novelty piece and not grounded in actual science, there was a lot of truth to its experiential analysis. Maybe I will re-up that story for my audience here sometime. I will discuss what factors contribute to what wine I’m drinking right now and then a little bit about those wines.
Being a wine club member at several Finger Lakes, NY wineries and a local and NYS wine expert, there is a good chance I will be sipping a local favorite or a yummy library wine. By the way, Congratulations to the Finger Lakes Wine Region for being named 2025 Wine Enthusiast’s “Best American Wine Region”.
When people ask me what wine to pair with the food they are having, I immediately provide them with an official answer. But unless they are having a formal wine dinner that costs $100/person or trying to impress their guests, wine collector, or hard to please father-in-law, I will always say “Drink what you like” or “Drink what you are in the mood for”. I know that doesn’t sound very wine snobbish or pretentious of me, but it’s my wine rule. Food and wine pairings are a massive topic, so I won’t focus too much on them for this post.
When selecting a bottle of wine, think “what I’m in the mood for”, “what am I eating”, and “who am I with”. Is the occasion casual or special? Will the bottle be finished? If not, will I or others finish it in the next few days? Similarly, if you’re feeling adventurous and open to trying something new, choosing a bottle gets way more complex, but exciting at the same time. As long as you’re willing to poke around and do a bit of research—or better yet, take some advice from yours truly, the journey promises to hold a myriad of interesting wines ahead.
If you’re having guests over, take into consideration that everyone’s palate responds differently to flavor profiles—being respectful of that will set you up for a successful selection. Refreshing rosé and sparkling wines set a festive tone—having some of both on hand is never a bad thing. And they are delicious year-round.
When choosing a wine to bring to a dinner party, showing up with bottles that have been chilled properly in advance and stored in a cooler while you travel to your destination allows you to enjoy them upon arrival. Take note of the optimal serving temperatures of the wine and plan ahead. If you need help with, please let me know. Start a wine journal – jot down the winery name, vintage, varietal, and how you served it. Don’t forget to snap a photo of the label to make finding it even easier in the future.
During the fall season (see previous blog post on fall wine pairings), I like to slowly transition my palate to heavier/more medium-full bodied, darker fruit wines, particularly single varietal reds or oaked Chardonnay. As I approach the winter season, I will tend to reach for a bottle that speaks to coziness, warmth, complexity, and festive in nature. Think sparkling (festive), red blends, ports (warm and heavy), dessert wines (sweet and cozy), and fortified wines (sweet, heavy, and strong).
Within those wine choices, I like to grab an obscure wine from a small region that is moderately priced, has good value, and contains a grape that I’m not overly familiar with. There are tons of international and hybrid grapes I have never tried. How to spot a good value wine is by market research, subscribing to a wine publication, like Wine Spectator or Decanter, or looking at the consensus or user ratings from multiple forums and sites.
For budget considerations, my rule of thumb, for example, for a typically high-priced Burgundy from France or Cabernet Sauvignon from the Finger Lakes, is under $30 USD and received a 90 plus score. For a lower-priced varietal, like a Rose or Riesling, with a score of 90 plus, I will look at under $20 USD.
The reality is that, even though I’m a wine purist, I will always recommend drinking your favorite grape/wine for any occasion and if it makes you happy and pairs well with your grub, then that’s a bonus. Don’t think less of me, but I’ve been drinking a reputable box wine called “Black Box”. Not all box wine is created equal. if I want to have something to drink over the course of a week, drinking alone, or just need to unwind, then a $24 USD box (three standard bottles of wine/box) satisfies. Who am I trying to impress? Maybe I should invest in a Coravin so I can drink better wine.
Cheers,
Michael
michael@michaelpour.com
