The Best Reds in the Finger Lakes Wine Region

Artist rendering of Finger Lakes Wine Region
January
13
2026

For this week’s post, I am dedicating it to my good friend and follower Janis @hummingbird512 on Instagram. She is a huge fan of wine, but more specifically, of Finger Lakes wine, and asked me to profile the best FLX reds out there for her to try and stock up on. She considers herself to be a local wine historian.

One of Janis’ favorite FLX wineries is McGregor Vineyards situated on a hillside just one mile above the eastern shore of Keuka Lake. She enjoys all of their wines, but especially the 2021 Cabernet Sauvignon. She had it this past summer and suggests holding on to it for a while because it will age beautifully.

She also likes to visit Dr. Konstantin Frank, pioneer for wine in the FLX. “Dr. Frank is uniquely located on the southwestern slopes of Keuka Lake. In 1958, Dr. Frank planted the first vinifera vines and ignited the Vinifera Revolution. This movement would forever change the course of winemaking in the Finger Lakes region”, Janis said. She also likes to go to Fox Run Winery and Zugibe Vineyards off of Seneca Lake.

Janis also loves Bubbles, as in sparkling, which pairs well with her bubbly personality. She has always been a huge supporter of me and my wine adventures, so I am thrilled to put this together for her. She has many followers on Instagram and loves to share her wine experiences, often with her daughter. Check her out! She is very engaging!

Below you will find the results from the annual New York Wine Classic through the NY Wine & Grape Foundation. I highlighted the highest scoring reds from this competition. NYWGF partners with the Beverage Testing Institute to judge wines submitted by wineries. Scores are awarded by a trained sensory panel comprised of beverage directors, sommeliers, top bartenders, retail buyers, and educators. 

Unfortunately, I wasn’t one of the judges, but I did carefully go through the list and highlight my personal recommendations. I listed those wineries that produce excellent reds and noted the varietal(s) you must try from that winery with some images. I also indicated where you can find the wineries in the Finger Lakes. 

Gold Medals were awarded to wines scoring above 90 pts. There were many excellent FLX reds above 90 in 2025, but I had to cap it at 92 pts and above. Note: Some wineries don’t participate in the NY Wine Classic so they won’t be represented. That’s not say that they don’t produce great reds, i.e. Shalestone Vineyards, Shaw Vineyards, Domaine LeSeurre, Winery, and McGregor Vineyards.

There are multiple AVA’s in the Finger Lakes so the AVA is listed. Most are Finger Lakes AVA, but some are Seneca Lake AVA and Cayuga Lake AVA depending on where grapes are grown and legal designation. Keuka Lake does not have an AVA so they will be designated as Finger Lakes AVA.

Best in Class –

Best Cabernet Franc – Ravines Wine Cellars 2022 Estate Cabernet Franc, Finger Lakes, 96 pts, Platinum Medal

Best Blaufrankisch/Lemberger – Heron Hill Winery 2023 Ingle Vineyard Blaufrankisch, Finger Lakes, 96 pts, Platinum Medal

Best Syrah – Hector Wine Company 2022 Syrah, Finger Lakes, 93 pts, Gold Medal

Top Red Wines –

Acquilano Wine Cellars 2023 Blaufrankisch, Finger Lakes, 95 pts, Gold Medal

Adirondack Winery 2021 Cabernet Franc “Autumn in the Park”, Finger Lakes, 94 pts, Gold Medal 

Red Newt Cellars 2023 Cabernet Franc, Finger Lakes, 94 pts, Gold Medal

93 pointers & Gold Medal –

Damiani Wine Cellars 2023 MC2 Red Blend, Finger Lakes

Goose Watch Winery 2020 “Bailey Sue” Reserve Cabernet Sauvignon, Finger Lakes

Inspire Moore Winery & Vineyard 2022 “Wisdom” Cabernet Franc, Finger Lakes

Ryan William Vineyard 2020 Reserve Syrah, Finger Lakes

Ryan William Vineyard 2020 Reserve Merlot, Finger Lakes

Sheldrake Point Winery 2022 Reserve Cabernet Sauvignon, Cayuga Lake

Sheldrake Point Winery 2023 Estate Cabernet Franc, Cayuga Lake

Thirsty Owl Wine Company 2023 Pinot Noir, Finger Lakes

Toast Winery 2023 MJ Red Blend, Finger Lakes

92 pointers & Gold Medal –

Buttonwood Grove Winery 2022 “Marnie Ann” Red Blend, Cayuga Lake

Chateau LaFayette Reneau 2020 Estate Merlot, Seneca Lake

Chateau LaFayette Reneau 2023 Estate Cabernet Sauvignon, Seneca Lake

Constantia Wine Company 2021 Uniquity Red Blend, Finger Lakes

Constantia Wine Company 2023 Cabernet Sauvignon, Finger Lakes

Dr. Konstantin Frank Winery 2022 Cabernet Franc, Finger Lakes

Hector Wine Company Sawmill Creek Estate 2022 Cabernet Franc, Finger Lakes

Knapp Winery 2022 Cabernet Franc, Finger Lakes

Lucas Vineyards 2022 Reserve Estate Collection Cabernet Franc, Finger Lakes

Point of the Bluff Vineyards NV June Bug Red Blend, Finger Lakes

Ventosa Vineyards 2020 Merlot, Seneca Lake

Wagner Vineyards Estate Winery 2022 Cabernet Franc, Finger Lakes

Other Gold Medal Winners from the New York Wine Classic below.  I did not list them here if they were included in the awards section above, so this is essentially a bonus list. 

Many newer wineries have popped up over the last couple of years in the Finger Lakes, which I have yet experienced, so the list will not include some of them.

I may be a little biased because I am either a wine club member at some of these wineries, have worked with them in some capacity, or visit them often because of their phenomenal red wine program. Enjoy!

What FLX reds am I drinking now – All reds from Damiani Wine Cellars, including exquisite library reds. You must seek them out. Just finished “Departure Red Blend” (CS, CF, Merlot) from Barnstormer Winery, Cab Franc from Long Point Winery, and Saperavi from Airy Acres Vineyard.

Damiani Wine Cellars, east-side Seneca Lake (try Pinot Noir & Reserve Cab Sauv). Wine Club member. Say hello to my friend and tasting room manager, Jeremy, and wine educator, Jenna, when you visit. They are second to none for their enormous and lovely library red program.

Airy Acres Vineyard, west-side Cayuga Lake (try Lemberger and Betty’s Blend, pictured). Wine Club member. Say hello to my friend, winemaker, and owner, Noah, when you visit. They are fairly new in the FLX and have been producing some incredible wines and reds

Lamoreaux Landing Wine Cellars, east-side Seneca Lake (try special Unoaked Cab Franc). I used to be the wine educator and director of marketing and public relations.

Sheldrake Point Winery, west-side Cayuga Lake (try Gamay Noir and Appassimento red dessert wine). Former wine educator there

Fox Run Vineyards, west-side Seneca Lake (try Cab Sauv and fortified Tawny Port)

Bright Leaf Vineyard, east-side Cayuga Lake (try Merlot). Say hello to owners, Donna & Mike, for me when you visit.

Six Eighty Cellars, west-side Cayuga Lake (try semi-carbonic Cab Franc). Say hello to winemaker, Ian.

Shaw Vineyards, west-side Seneca Lake (reds only). Say hello to Mr. Shaw and family

Forge Cellars, east-side Seneca Lake (try Pinot Noir)

Barnstormer Winery, west-side Seneca Lake (try Cab Sauv and fortified Ruby Port)

Shalestone Vineyards, east-side Seneca Lake (reds only)

Domaine LeSeurre Winery, east-side Keuka Lake (try Lemberger). Say hello to French owners, Celine & Sebastian, for me when you visit. Former assistant tasting manager and wine educator there

Red Tail Ridge Winery, west-side Seneca Lake (try Blaufrankisch and rare Teroldego, Lagrein, and Dornfelder. Last 3 from Italy are unique and worth exploring). Former tasting room manager and wine club manager there

McGregor Vineyard, east-side Keuka Lake (try Pinot Noir)

Nathan K/Hickory Hollow winery, west-side of Seneca Lake (try Cab Franc and library reds, pictured)

Long Point Winery, east-side of Cayuga Lake (try Cab Franc). Say hello to my friend, Women for Wine Sense colleague, and up-and-coming winemaker extraordinaire, Kristen. She is awesome!

Any questions or in need of recommendations for an organized wine tour or wineries to visit based on taste preferences, feel free to reach out and I can help you put together a tour to enhance your wine experience. Through my business, The Michael Pour, I am available to be your tour guide and concierge. The Finger Lakes Wine Region has been voted as the “Best Wine Region” in multiple years by consumers.

I’m no longer based in beautiful FLX wine country, but I continue to maintain close relationships with wine people and the wineries there. Look through the blog to read about my previous posts on the Finger Lakes Wine Region here – http://www.michaelpour.com/blog

Check out previous post about what “The Michael Pour” can do for you here – Interested In Learning More About Finger Lakes Wines? – The Michael Pour

Cheers,

Michael

What wines are we drinking right now?

Fall wine
October
29
2024

Does the season of the year guide our wine preferences? 

Short answer, yes, absolutely! Is it socially acceptable to drink your favorite or go-to wine even if it is technically a seasonal sip? Yes! My recommendation is always – drink what you like, first and foremost, then consider expanding your palate to accommodate what you are feeling at the moment or what foods will best accompany the wine.

In the spring and summer months, many wine drinkers tend to drink rosé and whites for their lightness, aromatics, crispness, floral components, and refreshing traits. In the northern hemisphere, the release and anticipation of the new vintage of rosé wine coinciding with the beginning of spring. In the fall/winter months, wine drinkers will transition to drinking more red wine, heavier whites, like oaked Chardonnay, and fuller bodied wines.

The seasonal nature and availability of produce and food also dictates our pallet and wine pairing choices. For this fall, try different oaked chardonnays from around the globe, orange wines (more on these later), and red wines, like Pinot Noir, Merlot, Sangiovese, Valpolicella, Cabernet Franc, and Malbec. If you’re a fan of bubbly, you can drink it anytime.

Fall wine glass

What wine would you recommend for Fall? 

Being a wine lover, I certainly have my preferences as I’m sure you do as well, but I like to explore new wines, styles, and regions. I will reach for that bottle of red most of the time, but if I’m having wine with food, I will definitely try to enhance the experience by choosing a wine that pairs well.

For fall, I like to drink Rhone varietals such as Grenache (red), Syrah (red), and Viognier (white, similar in style to Chardonnay), and most reds, although I prefer lighter to medium styles most of the time. You can find really good Rhone blends (called GSM blends with the ‘M” referring to Mourvèdre) or single varietals from the US, France, Barossa Valley in Australia and South America.  More widely available than ever. Stylistically, all these Rhone varietals have vibrant fruit balanced with savory, spice, earthiness, herbal and vegetal flavors that pair very well with the flavors of fall, like cool climate vegetables that can be roasted, braised, or sauteed. Don’t be afraid to venture out and try different red wines, especially for your holiday events and gatherings. I think Cabernet Franc is a lovely turkey day wine with all the accompaniments and a very underrated wine overall. I like CF all year long.

Classic Reds

Classic reds are always in style and continue to be the season’s most popular wine choices. Not just because they are ‘red’ and are bolder and fuller than whites, but because the rich flavor profiles that can range from dark fruits to earthy undertones, robust reds provide the perfect accompaniment to the season’s hearty dishes like roasts, stews, and casseroles and holiday celebrations. These classics include Cabernet Sauvignon, Merlot, Pinot Noir, or a red blend, like Bordeaux blend. If you opt for one of these, then try to find high quality ones (not necessarily the most expensive ones) in their category. Low quality vs. high quality fuller, red wines offer a very different experience.

Don’t forget about winter whites

Just because the sun and warm temperatures have hibernated for the season doesn’t mean you have to ditch white wine altogether. There are plenty of full-bodied, cozy whites that will work just as well as heavier reds with your fall cuisine and to drink by themselves. As mentioned earlier, an oaky Chardonnay always has a place at any holiday table. I look to Burgundy, France, Washington State, US, or South Africa for my Chard and Chablis for lighter/hybrid styles. Some trendy whites, like Viognier and Chenin Blanc are on the rise. When choosing your white wine in cooler weather, look for flavor profiles and textures that are rich, chewy, nutty, or creamy. These types of wines are usually fermented and/or aged in oak barrels and undergo malolactic fermentation, which gives them those traits.

Orange Wine

What other wines are trending right now? 

Orange wines have been growing trend the past few years. Orange wines have been around for a long time, dating back over 8000 years when, without modern wine making technology, all wines were fermented on the skins of the grapes, which is what gives wine its color. They were left in a pot to stew and ferment and the skins turned them a dark amber shade. Wine making was modernized in the 60s and 70s and the skins were removed to produce the lighter, fresher, cleaner style of common crisp whites like Sauvignon Blanc and Pinot Grigio we know today.

They are considered a ‘white wine’ that has been fermented with the skins on. Orange wines undergo a similar wine making process as reds where they are in contact with the skins during fermentation, so they take on the intensity of the colors and tannins, giving them a richer, heavier body. Today, there is a demand for orange wines to be less macerated, lighter, and fruitier, but still have some color and tannin structure. You will have to search hard to find orange wines in the marketplace, but if you like fuller bodied white wine, give them a try.

What else is trending in the wine world?

There is definitely a conscious shift toward natural, organic, vegan, and biodynamic wine and what that means. People are conscious about sulfite content, agricultural practices, and the environment. The grape skins used for orange wines are usually thicker and more resistant to pests and disease, so they are not treated as much and the tannins help protect them from oxidation, so they don’t need as much manipulation, sulfur or other preservatives. If this info is important to you, look for it on the back or front label or do a search online for bottles that are environmentally conscious.

Rosé wine is becoming more popular year-round evidenced by the hashtags #roseallday #roseeveryday all over social media and the internet. Many wineries are now producing different Rosés every year and experimenting with different grape combinations for them.

The public is more open to canned wine options these days, which started out of convenience, but has since lead to wineries putting higher quality products into this accessible format because of its popularity.

Pét-Nat (short for Petillant Natural) is a sparkling wine that has really taken off in colder climates. Unlike traditional champagne, it finishes its fermentation in the bottle and is not disgorged. Many different white grape varieties are used for this style of wine and can be a white blend.

Stocking your cellar/wine rack for Fall

The first thing you should do, as with other seasons, is to stock wines that you love to drink. From there, add wines that your family and close friends like just in case they visit unexpectedly or you have a last minute dinner party. Don’t be afraid to stock obscure wines or wines that seem interesting to you. Have fun with it! Take a chance – you might find something you never heard of and like it. I’m often asked what my favorite wine is. To me, it’s a loaded question because I like a lot of different wines (even though I will pull a red most of the time) and really depends on the occasion, what you’re feeling, and season (which is what this post is all about). Since most of my audience and guests are probably not wine experts, I try to introduce the world of wine to them one glass at a time. It’s amazing the excitement derived from people when they discover a new wine or style.

Try to curate your fall cellar with as many different wines as you can. Start with the most well-known grapes and wines and go from there. Here is an example – Pinot Noir, Cabernet Franc, Merlot, Cabernet Sauvignon, Champagne/Sparkling Wine, Rosé, Sauvignon Blanc/Sancerre, Pinot Gris/Grigio, Chardonnay (oaked), and Riesling (dry and semi-dry). If you would like to know what specific region or country of origin is best, just reach out. For the holiday season, chilling a nice dessert wine, like a Sauternes, ice wine, late harvest Riesling, or fortified wine, like Port, for dessert, is a nice touch and would impress your guests.

Some additional wines to stock up on for the season (reds) – Malbec, Syrah/Shiraz, Carmenere, Zinfandel, Grenache, Gamay/Beaujolais, Nebbiolo, Chianti, Lambrusco, Primitivo, Tempranillo/Rioja

We all look forward to holiday feasts and celebrations that come with the fall and winter months. Because no true celebration is complete without the perfect bottle or bottles of wine for you and your guests, I wanted to share these trends and options.

Follow me @themichaelpour on Instagram and The Michael Pour on Facebook to see more wine recommendations, advice, and inspiration. Sign up on the homepage with your email to receive notifications when articles are poured. Share with others who may enjoy this content.

Cheers,

Michael

Wine Glass

DON’T MISS A DROP

Get notified when new articles are poured

We don’t spam!