The Michael Pour -

What’s Pouring: Great Value 2023 California Pinot Noir

September

2025

The 2023 vintage of California Pinot Noir is considered to be one of the best vintages in a very long time. According to Wine Spectator, the composite score for all the Cali Pinot Noir is a whopping 96 points.

Personally, I don’t tend to gravitate toward Pinots from California because of their style and high price point, but there are some worth pursuing from this outstanding vintage. The criteria I use for a great value wine, specifically Pinot Noir, which is generally more expensive and difficult to grow and produce on a year-to-year basis, is under $40 USD and a minimum score of 90 points from multiple rating sources. Most highly rated PN from California will cost you between $60-$100, with some well above $120.

Why was this vintage so spectacular? If you are a wine guru or want to learn more the magical transformation of grape to wine, here is a deep dive into the factors that helped make this so.

The 2023 California Pinot Noir vintage may go down in history as one of the best because of the wet, cold winter that replenished and fortified soils, followed by a long, slow, cool growing season with mild temperatures. This allowed for gradual ripening and optimal development of flavor, acidity, and balance in the grapes. The extended “hang time” on the vines resulted in complex, vibrant wines with remarkable balance and structure.

The best regions can be found in the Russian River Valley, Sonoma Coast, Santa Barbara, Sta. Rita Hills, Napa Valley, and Anderson Valley.

Beneficial Winter Rains: Abundant rainfall during the winter months revitalized the soils, improving nutrient availability for the vines and promoting healthy canopy growth.

Extended, Mild Growing Season: Cooler spring and summer temperatures created an unusually long and temperate growing season.

Gradual Ripening: This slow, even ripening allowed the grapes to develop complex flavors and aromas while maintaining vibrant acidity.

Enhanced Acidity: The cool weather and extended maturity period resulted in higher acidity, which is crucial for the balance and aging potential of Pinot Noir.

Optimal Balance: Vintners achieved a rare balance of ripe fruit flavors, balanced sugar levels, and lively acidity, a hallmark of a great vintage.

Increased Yields: The healthy vine canopies and improved soil conditions led to above-average yields for Pinot Noir.

The result – vibrant flavors, remarkable balance, and excellent age-ability solidified its place as a benchmark year for California Pinot Noir.

Karen MacNeil, author of “The Wine Bible”, one of my favorite wine books, said this “Every century, every place has its legendary vintages. I have no doubt that 2023 will go down as one of the most phenomenal vintages ever in Napa Valley. Every vintner I’ve talked to about 2023 has been nothing short of ecstatic.”

Look for these best buy Pinot Noirs from this vintage. Many of them will be difficult to find in your local shops but should be available online.

Rivers-Marie Pinot Noir Sonoma Coast 2023, 94 pts, $40

Failla Pinot Noir Sonoma Coast 2023, 93 pts, $36

Alma De Cattleya Pinot Noir Sonoma County 2023, 92 pts, $35

Sean Minor Pinot Noir Sonoma Coast Signature Series 2023, 92 pts, $28

Morgan Pinot Noir Santa Lucia Highlands Twelve Clones 2023, 91 pts, $39

Truchard Pinot Noir Napa Valley Carneros 2023, 91 pts, $38

BONUS –

2023 was also good vintage for Oregon Pinot Noir, which experienced similar climate and weather conditions. Here is short list of some of those value wines:

Elk Cove Pinot Noir Willamette Valley 2023, 92 pts, $34

Ken Wright Pinot Noir Eola-Amity Hills 2023, 92 pts, $38

Solena Pinot Noir Willamette Valley Planet Oregon 2023, 90 pts, $24

Cheers, Michael Nagy

The Michael Pour

(Cover photo courtesy of Wine Spectator & James Molesworth, this story is not used for monetization)

New York’s Macari Vineyards: A Winery Spotlight

February

2025

by Michael Nagy

When we are planning a trip to a wine region, how do we decide where to go? Are we influenced and steered by trip advisor, yelp, word of mouth, things to do, styles of wine, or winery reviews? Maybe our motivations are to visit and experience a new wine region or taste a style of wine from a unique climate, terroir, or grape-growing environment? How about the wineries themselves? Do they offer a full or an all-inclusive tasting and hospitality experience?

Whatever your reasons, this story highlights one of my favorite wineries that are producing excellent, terroir-driven, and highly rated wines from an area, which is generally not thought of as a wine destination. Macari Vineyards, located on the North Fork region of Long Island in New York, is a sustainable, biodynamic family run vineyard and winery in the town of Mattituck. The Macari family is involved in every aspect of the winemaking and viticulture. The first grape vines were planted in 1995.

The Mattituck Tasting Room sits on the edge of the 500-acres (formerly a potato farm in the 1960’s) offering guided and tailored tasting experiences for small and large groups. These tasting experiences can occur on the covered deck or in the production cellar where all the magic happens. If you prefer a private experience, you can book the Private Tasting Suite.

Macari prides itself on offering seasonal tastings, food and wine pairings with gourmet cheese, charcuterie, pizza, and local fare for a cool brunch, lunch, or special event dinners. The style of wine crafted by Macari makes them very food friendly and versatile for all occasions throughout the year.

Macari has an off-site location called the Meadowlark North Fork featuring a wine bar and a wedding/event venue. The Wine Bar is a modified tasting room that offers unique selections of the Macari portfolio by the glass or bottle. Here the focus is on limited wines and innovative winemaking techniques available only at the Meadowlark property.

This wine bar is where guests can explore new tastes and unwind in the gardens. It is a great option for get-togethers, unique happenings and events, and a relaxing getaway for guests who desire to commune in nature without the hustle and bustle of a busy tasting room environment. Great place to experience the beautiful sights of the North Fork and have a picnic lunch.

What about the wines?

If you like balanced, nuanced, and age-worthy wines, then Macari wines will satisfy you and your guests’ palate throughout the whole year. Please see previous blog post to learn more about what makes wine from this region special to wine enthusiasts and different from other New World wines. The climate, microclimates, soil, latitude, longitude, diurnal temperatures, and proximity to water available to Macari allows for a unique expression of cool-climate wines similar to Bordeaux, but with some slight differences, like the salinity.

A follow-up post will discuss their award-winning wines from their portfolio along with tasting notes and technical information for those who want a deeper dive. Below is a brief list of some of those outstanding wines and some of the wines I will feature next time.

2023 Sparkling Horses Cabernet Franc

2023 Sauvignon Blanc Lifeforce

2022 Cabernet Franc Lifeforce

2021 Bergen Road Red Blend

2014 Block E White Blend

Cheers,

Michael Nagy

Getting to Know the Long Island Wine Region of NY

February

2025

by Michael Nagy

On the largest island in the contiguous US, you will find diverse wine styles from well-structured red wines to refreshing white, rosé, and sparkling wines. The North Fork of Long Island, which is located 75 miles east of New York City, is known for its tranquil waterfront charm, pebble beaches, lush farmland and rich vegetation, and wealth of family-run and sustainable vineyards.

The Long Island American Viticultural Area (AVA) has a similar maritime climate to the classic Bordeaux Region of France due to its proximity to the Atlantic Ocean. With being surrounded by water, the area is well protected from the cold and harsh winter seasons and the hottest summers, which is ideal for growing Bordeaux-type varieties.

Unlike other regions in New York, Long Island has always focused on Vitis vinifera grapes because it’s a warmer climate. It doesn’t have to focus just on cool climate and hybrid varieties. Even though it has a warmer climate, Long Island has the tumultuous Atlantic Ocean influence, which is why many vineyards are located in the North Fork sub-region of Long Island. The vineyards here are protected by the Peconic Bay around the island.

Terroir

Terroir is a French term literally meaning ‘sense of place’ describing the growing conditions for wine grapes. As mentioned earlier, Long Island has a very similar climate to Bordeaux but is a little warmer. With more growing days and hours of sunshine, you might expect riper styles of wine. In fact, Long Island has the same latitude as hot Barcelona, Spain. However, because of the cold Atlantic Ocean, Long Island wines tend to be ripe, but not over ripe or jammy compared to traditional warm climates, like California, Spain, and Australia.

One of the other factors affecting grape-growing in Long Island is the higher amount of precipitation, but the free draining, indigenous sandy soils and glacial moraines remaining from the last Ice Age drain away any excess water. This prevents the grapes from becoming bloated causing increased sugar levels, which can be catastrophic for dry wines.

The combination of adequate sunshine, moderately warm weather, gravelly and sandy soils, and proximity to the ocean leads to juicy red wines that are not overly tannic, heavy, or high in alcohol. The resulting red wines have savory aromas and characteristics, and white wines are high in acid with a unique saline profile not found too often in other wine regions around the world.

Long Island Wines

There are Bordeaux varieties, such as Merlot, Cabernet Franc, and Cabernet Sauvignon, but also traditional-method Chardonnay and Pinot Noir, some edgy styles of Pet Nat, and orange wines. Many of the wines, thanks to the cooling influence of the Atlantic, are lower in alcohol, around 11-12.5%, with lighter styles from Bordeaux and fresh fruit flavors.

Sub-Regions of Long Island

The main AVA is Long Island but, in reality, the main spot where most vineyards are planted is in North Fork, thanks to the protection of Peconic Bay. However, people can source grapes from the entire Island where you will see Long Island AVA on the label.

North Fork of Long Island

The North Fork of Long Island is warmer than the rest of Long Island (including the Hamptons) and receives more sunshine leading to wines with riper fruit flavors and fuller bodies, and often higher alcohol compared to other NY regions in New York. The North Fork of Long Island AVA was established in 1986, sixteen years before Long Island AVA.

Over the last 10 years or so, the North Fork has enjoyed a major evolution with critical acclaim from wine experts and the international wine community. I have become fascinated with the quality and versatility of their wines that I started to use North Fork wines for my company events and wine tastings with clients as well as enjoying them myself and in my travels. Look for their wines to be featured and reviewed here and on social media.

One winery in particular whom I’ve recently become an unofficial brand ambassador for is Macari Vineyards. Macari Vineyards, whose 500 acres features a beautiful and spacious tasting room and covered deck where top-end red flights, a bottle of the cult-favorite ‘Horses’ Pet-Nat, and award-winning Merlot, Cabernet Franc, and Bergen Road Red Blend are paired with charcuterie, cheese, and other delicacies.

Macari’s wine estate, which is biodynamic and sustainable, is located in Mattituck overlooking scenic Long Island Sound. The property has been in the family for over 40 years spanning three generations using traditional farming methods. The family themselves nurture the soil and vines. Nearby, Meadowlark, Macari’s sister property, pours small-batch wines and hosts events. Visit their site at the hyperlink above. I look forward to a visit there soon.

The Hamptons of Long Island

Established in 1985, this southern part of the island is better known for celebrity beach houses and where affluent New Yorkers go to get away from it all. However, it’s also a great place for refreshing wines from Long Island, particularly rosé and sparkling wines. Cooler than the North Fork due to massive exposure to the Atlantic Ocean, you can expect higher acid content in the wine along with lighter styles and zesty white wines.

Quick Facts:

There are 90 Wineries in Long Island as of 2022.
Largest island in the contiguous United States.
Established May 15, 2001.
New vineyards planted in 1973 in North Fork sub-region.
1815 acres of vineyards planted.
First vineyards were planted in the 1820s, but all succumbed to disease pressure.
Over half the planted acres in Long Island are in the dedicated sustainability program (LISW).
Merlot is the most planted grape variety in Long Island.

As the parent of the super popular Cabernet Sauvignon, Cabernet Franc is often overshadowed by its own progeny. It also the parent of Merlot. However, this underrated grape produces some very good, complex, and food-friendly wines that are the best in the world mirroring those from Loire Valley and Bordeaux, France. Cab Franc is truly the signature red grape of Long Island and all of NY.

Wines made from Cab Franc range from light and quaffable to rich and tannic depending on both region and winemaking styles. Cool-climate examples from the Loire Valley, Finger Lakes, or Long Island can be lively and fresh with tart red fruit, green pepper notes, and better than average acidity.

They can be aged in stainless steel for a punchier red fruit expression and lighter style or in oak barrels to add hints of cedar, tobacco, and spice with fuller body. Cabernet Francs from warmer sites like Napa Valley and Paso Robles can result in bigger wines with juicy, ripe fruit, and typically a heavier oak influence with use of American or new oak barrels.

Cheers,

Michael Nagy, michael@michaelpour.com

Wine of the Week: A Hot Trip to Italy’s Boot

January

2025

by Michael Nagy

I wanted to get this “wine of the week” out to you before I take a road trip to Saratoga, NY this week. With the recent loss of my precious Marty kitty this past week, I need a change of scenery.

For this week’s wine of the week, I take a trip down to the hot climate of the Puglia region along the Adriatic Sea in southeast Italy where the Primitivo grape is widely produced. Puglia is a dry, sun-drenched region that has one of the most intense sun in all of Italy. The entire east side is along the coastline bordering the Adriatic Sea.The climate is moderated by the Adriatic and Ionian seas, which provide constant, cooling maritime winds.

This unique climate helps produce exquisitely balanced fruit and is well-suited for the production of concentrated, fruity and spicy red grape varieties, like Primitivo. Puglia’s Mediterranean climate and iron-rich, calcareous soils support the native Primitivo by producing an inky, spicy, and brambly ripe red wine.

About half way down, the region becomes the Salento Peninsula. This peninsula, bordered by water on three sides, receives moist, nighttime, sea breezes that bring a welcome cooling effect to the region, where little rain creates a challenging environment for its vines. The region is named for the Italian expression, “a pluvia,” meaning “lack of rain.”

Loved for its fruit-forward wines, the Primitivo grape originated in Croatia. Here it was named from the Latin word, primativus, meaning “first to ripen.” Nobody knew until the early 90’s that Primitivo and Zinfandel were actually the same genetic grape. The grape is better known outside of Italy as Zinfandel, especially California.

California Zinfandel tends toward a sweeter, fruitier style than Primitivo. This is due to areas like Lodi that are hot during the day, and don’t really cool off that much at night. Napa Valley, and the Dry Creek Valley of Sonoma County, and in parts of New York state also produce it, but are usually lighter-bodied. Both can have a slight sweetness from ripe fruit, but Primitivo is usually made in an earthier, more tannic style.

The main traits of most Primitivo wines are fruity with notes of cherry, strawberry, blackberry, and raisin, earthy and rustic, big and jammy, high in alcohol, chewy tannins, and sometimes a sweet finish. It is no longer an obscure blending grape in Italy. It has become a symbol for high quality, inexpensive single varietal wines unlike many Italian red wines. Primitivo’s ripe fruit and full body make it a great partner with rich, meaty dishes.

Castello Monaci Piluna Primitivo 2021

I was first introduced to this lovely wine in 2023 when I was the General Manager at Portico Restaurant, high end Italian steakhouse, in del Lago Resort & Casino. Based on the recommendation from my sales rep and upon tasting, I was sold. I decided to add it permanently to my extensive wine list as well as “by the glass” program at a very moderate price.

Tasting Notes –

Aromas of ripe black fruit, dried red fruit, strawberry, and toasty vanilla and pepper spice. On the palate, hints of cherry, chocolate, and a berry basket. Medium bodied (most Primitivo is heavier), light-medium tannins (with bottle age, tannins have softened out today from my first tasting in 2023), low-medium acidity, and a fruity character at the end of the palate followed by an earthy finish. Even with some age and dried characteristics, it still has some freshness to it.

This featured wine from producer Castello Monaci, with its sustainability philosophy, stands out in the heart of the Salice Salentino DOC, which is located in Puglia in the “heel of the boot” of farthest southeast Italy. Each vineyard section is always cultivated and harvested at night to ensure the best quality of grapes. It has consistently received a 90-point rating from international reviewers overall several vintages. Drink now – not age worthy. Look for the 2023 vintage available now.

Cheers,

Michael

Wine of the Week: Little Known Red from Austria

January

2025

by Michael Nagy

I had the pleasure of sipping this wine over the holiday season with in-laws. It was a nice change of pace from what I typically drink even though it reminds me of a nice Pinot and Lemberger all in one bottle.

Did you know that the country of Austria produces some really good wine? Can they grow red grapes and produce red wine in their cold climate? Although Austria is better known for its white wine, it does grow and produce some surprisingly good reds that are unique to the red wine world.

Austria as a whole is still white wine country, but of the 30% or so red vineyards, the most widely planted grape is Zweigelt by far. Zweigelt (pronounced TSVY-galt) and other reds are nothing like the new world reds in California, Chile, Argentina, and Australia nor old world reds in France, Italy, and Spain. Austria’s reds are very similar in style to Germany reds.

Austria is a landlocked country in Central Europe, bordered by eight countries – Germany to the northwest, Czech Republic to the north, Slovakia to the northeast, Hungary to the east, Slovenia to the south, Italy to the southwest, and Switzerland to the west

Zweigelt is a relatively young grape variety, having been created in 1922. The grape is a cross between the St. Laurent and Blaufränkisch grape varieties, which are native to Austria. It is a versatile grape that is grown throughout Austria’s wine regions. It is well-suited to Austria’s cool climate, as it ripens early and is resistant to cold temperatures. This allows the grape to be grown in cooler, higher-altitude vineyards, which are not suitable for many other grape varieties.

When you go to buy red wine and looking for something new and different, consider Zweigelt, and in particular the one I’m featuring in this post as well as one from Weis Vineyards, German winery off Keuka Lake located in the beautiful Finger Lakes, NY. Weis also produces a Dry Rose from the Zweigelt grape. Check them out! They are one of the best wineries in New York State.

The grape generally produces medium-bodied wines with moderate acidity and tannins. The wine has a vibrant ruby color and aromas of dark berries, such as blackberry and black cherry, as well as spicy notes of pepper and cinnamon. On the palate, it has a smooth, velvety texture with flavors of dark fruit, warm spice, vanilla, and sometimes even a hint of chocolate.

Zweigelt is a very food-friendly wine that pairs well with a variety of dishes. It is especially good with meat dishes, like roasted pork, beef, lamb, and duck, as well as with hearty vegetable dishes and warm stews in the winter.

Zweigelt is also an excellent choice for those looking for a more affordable alternative to some of the more well-known red wine varieties. While it is not as well-known as some other grape varieties, Zweigelt is gaining popularity among wine lovers, both in Austria and abroad.

Austrian wine, in general, has gained a reputation for high quality and unique flavors, and Zweigelt is no exception. In recent years, Austrian winemakers have increasingly focused on producing high-quality Zweigelt wines, and the grape has been gaining recognition and awards at international wine competitions.

In all, Zweigelt is a versatile, affordable, and high-quality red wine grape variety that is gaining popularity among wine lovers worldwide. With its unique flavor profile and food-friendly nature, it is definitely worth trying for anyone looking for something new and exciting in the world of wine.

Schlosskellerei Gobelsburg Zweigelt, Niederosterreich, 2019 (cover photo)

Btw, German and Austria wines have very long wine names and sometimes hard to pronounce. This bottle of Zweigelt brings forth a nuttiness of almonds and dark cherries and berries on the nose along with a spicy and peppery aroma. It has a light-medium body and well balanced with enough acidity, although not crispy.

This Zweigelt offers a toasty character from some oak, but still fresh and youthful on the palate. It is a juicy, but elegant, energetic red wine with a nice aroma that lasts through the palate and medium finish. 12.5% alcohol.

It has reached its age of maturity in 2025 (not an age-worthy wine by tradition so drink now when it’s good). It is most likely at its peak for drinking.

Try this wine or search for more at your fine wine shop. Most local wine shops only carry 1-2 Zweigelts in inventory so call beforehand or just order this one online. You will not be disappointed! My rating is 8 out of 10 (very good). I won’t feature a wine unless it receives a score of 7 (good) and above. My personal rating system is out of 10; different from most professional ratings….Cheers, M